Poverty of Morals: Why Liberal Idealism Sucks
- George Grosz, The Pillars of Society (1926) This current historical moment is rife with evil, and philosopher Susan Neiman is right that the left should not shy away from naming these evils explicitly. In a recent interview published by Jacobin , Neiman argues for a return to the language of evil, pointing rightfully to the genocide in Gaza. As she notes, words like "Authoritarian" mask the reality of cold blooded slaughter of women, children, medics, journalists, etc. But it is here, right after naming the horror, where Neiman's argument collapses and flattens into anti-material, and by extension anti-reality nonsense. In setting out to reclaim a Kantian universal morality, Neiman dismisses the material reality that global capitalism creates by flattening class into an identity marker alongside race and gender. She argues that leaning too heavily on materialism is a detriment, suggesting instead that a universal moral framework has the power to change minds across ...